Talk:Alya Césaire/@comment-5646665-20180122033757

I have a comment to say about the episode with Alya getting a miraculous. What I have to say may not be popular, but please don't get angry with me for having an opinion.

I was not pleased about Alya getting a Miraculous and I have reasons I would like to state why she isn't ready for one in my opinion. Some that might make sense to others or not.

First, she has essentially no character growth to indicate she should have one. She is still very much more concerned with getting the latest for her blog or trying to interview Ladybug and Chat Noir. In fact, in the episode she didn't want to listen to Marinette when she tried to get her to see that learning the heroes identities was wrong.

My second reason is she was given it due to circumstances that led to making her sisters akumas. I understand her younger sisters were driving her mad, but I firmly believe that unless she said speciffically she was taking them to the amusement park, which the sub didn't indicate, she couldn't tell them it was off.

Third. While she was doing very good for her first time, she wasn't focusing on the mission a lot of the time. She was super excited about her powers and tried to one up experianced hero work. She even tried to get their numbers which shouldn't be the first thing on a heroes mind.

Fourth reason. She made a promise and tried to renegotiate on it. Just like her little sisters she demonstrated immaturity by trying to keep something that wasn't hers yet technically. It took a bit of guilt tripping to get her to give it back. Then she nearly blows it with Marinettte before remembering that what she said and did have consequences.

I am not saying Alya won't make a great heroine and that she should never get a Miraculous. I'm just saying in my opinion, at this time, she doesn't seem ready for one.