Talk:Hawk Moth/@comment-188.51.97.113-20160201165033/@comment-68.230.7.139-20160208230813

There are a few problems with that theory:

1. Well, if Gabriel was the "previous generation of Chat Noir" as you put it, then how is does he still have a miraculous if Adrien now has Plagg? He most likely, if he is Hawkmoth, had a different miraculous (most likely a hawkmoth...)

2. Here's the biggie... Um, wouldn't Tikki and Plagg TELL Adrien and Marientte who the Papillon is? I mean, if they know who he is, which they would if your theoy is correct, and they know what turned him evil and how he works, wouldn't their miraculouses tell them? Then they would know who the villian was a beat him.

3. I know that you were just making up the story, and yes it would be dramatic and really emotional, that doesn't seem the way the show is going, like Zeeva said. The show was intended for older teenagers, but when that didn't go through, they tried to make it a show that appealed to younger kids. Therefore, unless more teens start watching than younger kids, which might already be the case, I don't think it would go down that dark a road. But overall, the theory is pretty good. Perhaps his wife had a different miraculous.